HBO's 'The Yogurt Shop Murders' Reopens 1991 Austin Case

On August 3, 2025, HBO premiered a four-part documentary miniseries titled *The Yogurt Shop Murders*, bringing renewed attention to one of Austin, Texas's most notorious unsolved cases from 1991. The series, directed and produced by Margaret Brown, concludes on August 24, 2025.

The crime itself remains stark in its brutality. Four teenagers were shot and killed inside a yogurt shop located in a strip mall in Austin. The perpetrator then set the crime scene on fire, leaving investigators with a case that would perplex authorities for over three decades.

Brown's documentary delves beyond the basic facts of the killings to examine the human cost of the unsolved mystery. The series explores the trauma inflicted on victims' family members, offering intimate perspectives on how the crime affected those closest to the deceased. Through interviews with friends and loved ones, viewers gain insight into the emotional toll of living with an unresolved tragedy.

The investigation receives substantial scrutiny in the documentary. Featured investigators include John Jones and Paul Johnson, who served as lead detectives on the case, alongside homicide investigator Mike Huckabay and detective Dan Jackson. The series raises important questions about investigative techniques used during the inquiry, with particular attention paid to concerns about how certain methods may have contributed to potential false confessions—a troubling element that haunted the case for years.

The filmmaking behind the series is notable in itself. The concept originated from actress Emma Stone and director Dave McCary, with production company A24 initially set to produce. Margaret Brown came on board to direct after spending time in Austin and reviewing archival footage obtained by Claire Huie, giving the project deep local roots and access to rare materials.